Secondary 3 English Argument Evaluation Quiz

Secondary 3 English Quiz - Argument Evaluation

Name: ___________________________
Class: ___________________________
Date: ___________________________
Score: ___________ / 40

Duration: 60 minutes
Total Marks: 40

Instructions:
This quiz tests your ability to identify, analyse, and evaluate arguments in written texts. Read each passage and question carefully. Answer all 20 questions. Use your own words where instructed. Marks are shown in brackets [ ].

---

Section A: Identifying Arguments and Claims (Questions 1–5)

1. Read the statement below:
"Schools should ban mobile phones because students waste too much lesson time on social media."
What is the claim being made? [1]

---

2. In the sentence, "Exercise improves mood; therefore, everyone should jog daily," what word signals the conclusion of the argument? [1]

---

3. Identify whether the following is a fact or an opinion:
"The library closes at 8 p.m. on weekdays." [1]

---

4. Read the extract:
Jia Wei said, "Homework helps us revise. It should not be reduced."
What is Jia Wei's main argument? [1]

---

5. Underline the conclusion in this argument:
"Traffic is heavy. Buses are often late. Thus, the school should start later." [1]

---

---

Section B: Supporting Evidence and Reasoning (Questions 6–10)

6. Read the paragraph:
Jia Hui argues that canteen food is too oily. She says her friend vomited after eating fried noodles, and a survey showed 60% of students disliked the grease.
Give one piece of evidence Jia Hui uses to support her view. [1]

---

7. Explain why the evidence in Q6 (the survey) is stronger than the friend's experience. [2]

---

8. Read:
The writer claims tuition is necessary. He gives the example of a student who improved from D to A after 3 months of tuition.
Is this a strong support? State one weakness. [2]

---

9. Identify the assumption in this argument:
"All top scorers sleep early. Therefore, sleeping early makes you a top scorer." [1]

---

10. A poster states: "Vote for clean toilets! Our school ranks last in hygiene."
What type of appeal is used? (emotional / logical / authority) [1]

---

---

Section C: Evaluating Argument Strength (Questions 11–15)

11. Read the passage:
Some students want a longer recess. They say, "We are tired and need rest." Others say, "We already have 30 minutes; learning time is more important."
To what extent is the first group's argument convincing? Give one reason. [2]

---

12. The letter below argues for a new basketball court:

Generated source_image for Q12.

List two reasons from the letter that support building the court. [2]

---

13. Explain one way the argument in Q12 could be weakened. [2]

---

14. Read:
"Uniforms should be abolished. In some countries, students wear casual clothes and are happy."
Identify the flaw in reasoning. [2]

---

15. A debate speech says: "If we do not ban energy drinks, our cohort will fail. Look at Lee, who drank them and slept in class."
Evaluate the reasoning. State one mistake. [2]

---

---

Section D: Constructing and Responding to Arguments (Questions 16–20)

16. Write one counter-argument to: "CCTV in classrooms improves discipline." [2]

---

17. Read the extract:
Ms Tan: "Projects teach real skills." Mr Lim: "They waste time before exams."
Whose view is based on exam preparation? [1]

---

18. The article claims: "Reading novels is better than comics for vocabulary."
Suggest one piece of evidence the writer should add. [2]

---

19. To what extent do you agree that school assemblies should be shortened? Give two supporting points. [4]

---

20. Read the poster:

Generated poster for Q20.

Using the poster, state the argument and one evaluation of its strength. [3]

---